SHANY Dreamy Dozen Matte Lip Liner Set Vegan - Long-Lasting Professional Velvet Cruelty-Free Lipstick Pencils Pens in Varying Shades - Pack of 12

I purchased lipsticks from Shany cosmetics With these lip liners I’ve tried their eyeshadows as well because of them being so good I had to try the products! And let me tell you best investment I have done on amazon!! These are so affordable the packaging is to die for very high-quality these lip liners are extremely amazing! They have the right creaminess they don’t break and crumble on your lips like most the liners do! The colors are so good though with every type of lipstick you have! The size of the pencils are extremely perfect not too long not too short just right and they sharpen so perfect! I cannot believe how amazing these products are for the price these are high-quality products!! This is a must buy you will not be disappointed!! Definitely doing a review on my YouTube and Instagram!!!

Colors, quality, and value of this set is 5 stars! I love it! I highly recommend it!

The colors are pretty, but they are very dry and do not slide easily on the delicate skin of the lips, they look like colors to draw on paper

Me encanta este producto puedo usarlo para mis labios y crear combinacion de color la calidad es muy buena y a bajo precio

Colors are cool.

Matte finish long lasting color.. Some odd colors but I just mix them and works out.

The colors match no where close to the real colors in person. I was looking for cool toned pencils as shown in the picture. None of the lip liner were cool toned

Was not a fan of this product due to colors did not match. The pencil part did not apply color that is promoted on the box nor the tips of the colored pencils.