Revlon ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner, Smudge-Proof, Eye Makeup with Built-In Sharpener, 203 Brown, 0.01 oz

It’s a good color - not to dull or not too bright. It went on pretty well, and covered my lids without much of an issue. It blended easily - I like a muted line on top and bottom. Only issue is, I accidentally extended it too long and broke a large portion of it off. I guess that was my fault, and just hope it helps the next person not to make that mistake. The durability is nice, not sticky, but nice staying power. It’s also not hard to clean your eye makeup off, and that’s a big plus for me — I don’t like tugging on my lashes or under my eyes or anywhere around that delicate area. And, the texture, nice, long-lasting, and it is not sticky. I am presently surprised of the quality. I’m a happy customer.

I’ve been using the Revlon ColorStay Pencil Waterproof Eyeliner for a few months now, and I’m really impressed with the formula and performance. The pencil glides on smoothly without tugging, and the waterproof, smudge-proof formula really lives up to its name — it didn’t budge through a long day, heat, or humidity. I also like that it comes with a built-in sharpener, which makes it super convenient to keep a sharp tip without extra tools. The black shade is rich and deep, great for defining my eyes with either a subtle line or a more dramatic look. What I love: Long-lasting, really lives up to waterproof & smudge-proof Smooth application Two pencils in one pack = great value What could be improved: Slightly firm pencil tip at first — a little softer texture would be nice sharpener comes out easy Overall, for the price and performance, this eyeliner is a solid everyday choice — especially if you want long wear and reliable results.

Works amazing. It's the perfect color. Waterproof. It actually lasts all day. I wear contacts so my eyes water a lot. Very smooth when applying. Fair priced.

Goes on dark and easy. Great eyeliner. Stays on all night.

I love this stuff, it goes on easy and stays on all day, then washes off easily. Pretty, natural colors. Easy to lighten with your makeup sponge or fingertips.

Love using this. I’ve used this eyeliner for many years. Don’t smudge unless I smudge it. It blends in when slender with eyeshadow. Lasts a while and feels smooth when applied. Don’t bug my eyes. Easy to apply. Lasts all day. A lot of eyeliner in it, lasts over a month. Easy to remove with soap. Highlights my eyes nicely.

My favorite eyeliner! The pigment is good, stays on well!

While I love the very thin tip and the color for blue eyes, I don’t like the little “crumbles” it leaves here and there on my lids. And I don’t like using the silicone smudge end. I have found that I have to use an angled brush to soften and blend and then apply a similar eyeshadow over it in to hide the imperfections. It is not very blendable without adding another product and using something else other than the “silicone tip”. It glides on ok but as I mentioned it leaves little pieces or “balls” behind that can get messy when trying to clean up and takes extra time to complete. It is durable but I feel there are others that are just as durable with less fuss. For the money, it is a good value but I probably will not repurchase or recommend because I don’t want to use more products to clean up what this leaves behind, I want to simplify, not use extra angled brushes because the silicone tip doesn’t blend the product well or even completely removes it. Better out there, and on my no more high end simplified quest, I’m sure I’ll find something amazing! I am giving it 3 stars for the size of the tip and the shade of brown that I haven’t seen exactly. Not a light brown, dark brown or a true espresso.