ILIAClean Line Liquid Liner with Precision Tip | Quick Dry, Water Resistant, Smooth Application | Carbon Black-Free, Non-Toxic, Vegan, Cruelty-Free (Classic Black, 0.01 fl oz | 0.55 ml)

This eye liner is the same brand I found at Sephora. I have used it for years and love it. I don’t use it everyday, so one pen lasts me about 4 months. It does go on smooth and has a nice texture, it is a compact size that fits nicely in a small purse, and it is easy to apply and functional. It lasts a long time, all day with no smudges. This is the same brand as what is found at Sephora, but unfortunately not any cheaper. I have bought the Sephora brand and this the exact same product. Many times there are dupes, but not the case here.

Love this eyeliner works great it’s waterproof, dries quick, I got black, the color was great and stays on, didn’t smudge.

I LOVE this liner. It does have a thicker tip but the tip is highly flexible. So you can apply it thin, or angle your hand and make a thicker line, if that makes sense. I've tried the cat eye thing and messed up---it easily wiped away when you act quickly. I would NOT call this smudge proof--it definitely smudges...Nothing too bad but if you rub your eyes (allergies) it will smudge. I only use this as a top liner. I would buy again. I mainly bought due to its clean ingredients.

Very light, not black enough to even be noticeable on your face. And barely lasted 3 weeks. I wanted to support a vegan product but this was not worth the money at all. Do not purchase.

Easy to use and good price.

I absolutely adore all of Ilya's products. They are clean, high quality, and highly pigmented. Finding liquid eyeliner that is clean and in this tip style is near impossible, but this one works so well and it stays long.

I love their mascara and this company but their eyeliner was a miss. The felt tip is very sharp, smooth and runs on easily so I was hopeful. But it takes forever to dry and arguably never dries because it sinks and smudges way too easily. Transfers to my top lid and collects in the crease below my eye...not great. The best eyeliner for me is still Anastasia, definitely not non-toxic but holds so well.

I really wanted this liquid eyeliner to work, but it just didn't stay. By the end of the day, it was completely gone on the corner of my eyes. The consistency and the color are great; it's just that it doesn't last very long.