L'Oreal Paris L’Oreal Paris Makeup Infallible Grip Precision Felt Eyeliner, Smudge Resistant, Long Lasting Waterproof Eyeliner, Grey, Grey, 0.03 fl oz

I use this eyeliner for many years, it's affordable and it has grey shade which is perfect for my face. I like precise felt tip, very easy to use. The only cons that it doesn't stay on for the whole day, but for the price can't complain

Easy to apply. Great color.

Used two colors so far, brown and grey. Neither one irritated my eyes and did not lead to bloodshot eyes. And that's extremely rare for me with any kind of eye makeup, even the 'best brands'. I like the felt tip that draws a very fine line at lash line, and opacity is very good, seems more watery than most liners, but I'm liking it that way, doesn't go on too cakey. And of course the price is fantastic. My only con is it comes off with just water pretty easily; hard to understand why they call it 'waterproof', it's not. Got to shake it really well to get opacity right.

Gray is perfect for seniors

I have been wearing this eyeliner for years now and I am not changing anytime soon. I love the delicate tip and color. It lasts a long time and it's very easy to clean up.