The Lip BarStraight Line Eyeliner + Sharpener Kit | Easily Glides for Simple Application | Long-Lasting, Waterproof and Smudge-Proof | Infused with Jojoba Oil | Black

This liner is a gel texture and it is the smoothest, easiest to apply gel liner I've ever used. I didn't expect the formula to be this nice. You barely need any pressure to draw a deep, pigmented line. It does take a little while to dry down. Until it does, you can smudge it or blend it out if you want. Once it dries down it doesn't budge until you use makeup remover. It's very affordable and I will be ordering this eyeliner in the future.

The Lip Bar Straight Line Eyeliner is perfect for tight lining. The pencil is smooth and you don't need any pressure to deposit color. You'll want to be precise for this reason- any slight slip and you'll easily deposit color where you didn't intend to. The pencil is soft so you'll want to sharpen it often to keep a good point. Thankfully, a quality sharper is included with the pencil.The color is a deep dark black. It looks really striking on the eye. I also apply a thin line above the lash line and smudge it out. It smudges easily without wiping too much of your line off. You have enough time to smudge it out but after you're done applying/smudging, it stays put. I didn't have any problems with it smearing or smudging (after my intentional smudge) throughout the entire day of wearing it.One downside is that it is hard to remove. I had raccoon eyes after using my usual face cleanser so I went to task with some wipes. It took a lot of wiping, then micellar water and more wiping, then another face cleansing to remove the residue from the micellar water and MORE wiping. There was a little left after all that aggressive wiping. Since the remainder rubbed off in my sleep or my shower the next morning, it's not a huge problem. I'd probably reconsider applying this if I know anyone is going to see me after my nightly skin care routine or away from home where I may not have access to a heavy duty eye makeup remover.If this product were easier to remove, I'd give it 5 stars. The color is intense, the application looks really good and accentuates my eyes really well.

Great color but it is very soft.

My daughter loves it. It goes on smooth and last all day. It's her favorite! The color is on point and goes on smoothly.

This eyeliner is really nice but… it arrived with the tip broken off in the cap. I guess because the eyeliner formula is infused with Aloe vera, jojoba oil, coconut oil, and Vitamin E, it makes the eyeliner super soft and mushy.. which is probably why it arrived broken off and melted inside the cap. It comes with a sharpener which works well with the pencil. It does glide on the waterline really easily. It is a nice eyeliner set though.

This pencil draws a SMOOTH dark line. It goes on so easily, without needing to press hard. You have 8-10 seconds to blend and then it's basically set, so you have to work a little quickly if you're going for a smoky look.I haven't tried it on my waterline so I can't speak to that, but it holds up well on skin and is a bit difficult to remove. It will fade, though, if rubbed hard. (Obviously that is not recommended for the sensitive areas around the eyes, so using a quality remover is a necessity.)Pencil is made in Taiwan, and sharpener is made in Germany.

Good quality at a good price point. Goes on smoothly, lasts all day and is fairly easy to remove with makeup wipes. Good, solid color.

This is a great waterproof eyeliner that wears all day without much smudging. I have greasy skin, even around my eyes, and makeup tends to run halfway through the day. With this liner and the help of a little setting powder, my makeup looks pretty amazing even after 12 hours.I remove it with an oil-based eye makeup remover and it works like a charm. It would be otherwise very difficult to remove with just a facial cleanser. To me, that means it's a truly long-lasting liner.I think it's a great deal for the price. You get a pencil and a sharpener.