Milani Stay Put Matte Liquid Eyeliner Long Lasting 17hr- Black Matte | Quick-Drying, Humidity- And Sweat-Resistant Liquid Eyeliner With Up To 17Hr Matte Wear. Cruelty-Free. Made In Germany.

I used to use liquid eyeliner forever ago, then changed my look for some time and switched to pen liquid eyeliners simply for the ease of use and the super occasional eyeliner ... fast forward to today, I've been wanting to go back to the cat eye look with sharper lines and edges as I got tired from crayons drying out, dull lines, not opaque enough, etc... boy did I forget the power of the liquid eyeliner and its general existence. I got this one due to the good reviews, for the super black opaque and matte look that falls within my budget. It isn't waterproof and it smudges/wipes away if you physically wipe it with your finger (I don't really touch my face or eyes, so not an issue) but it stays put all day until I take it off, so in reality it doesn't smudge on its own at all. Personally, I understand the need for waterproof makeup but I have sensitive skin and the products needed to remove such makeup are too harsh so I prefer stuff that I can take off easily with regular old water and some cleanser. Also because of sensitive skin, this product does sting a tiny bit when applied at first closer to the edge of my eye, but it's only for a few seconds and I don't seem to have adverse effects overall. I had to practice a few times and still don't get the lines quite perfectly but for the price and what I get, it's such a step up from the products I have been using so far.

I have always preferred liquid liner to pencils, and I’ve probably tried every single liquid liner over the past 25 years. I’ll start by saying that I only use liquid liner on my waterline, so finding a product that actually stays in place is difficult. This product says 17hrs, but it could definitely last longer than that, as I work 13hr shifts, and it doesn’t budge, smear, or flake. It’s actually a bit hard to remove even with micellar water, so definitely waterproof. I love the matte look over shinier liners, and it dries super fast too.

I love this eyeliner. The color is very black and is easy to apply. I like that you can control how thick or thin you want to go. It is smudge resistant and most importantly it doesn’t irritate my eyes. Another plus is if you mess up you can fix it with a baby wipe without ruining your makeup. Highly suggest you try it.

Love the longevity, it's totally smudge proof after it dries, nice deep black color, honestly the formula is on point. My only complaint is the tip on the applicator is pretty thick so getting a sharp wing or thin line can be a little difficult, but after playing with it a bit I got the perfect winged liner I wanted. Overall I recommend, especially if you have an old liner brush you prefer to use with it.

I love this eyeliner. It’s easy to apply and I can wear it all day without any worries! My eyeliner tends to come off in the folds of my eyelids, even with primer and eyeshadow. But this one stays put. I think the applicator is fine, nothing special, but no issues. The formula goes on smooth and dark. No need to layer it. And it stays on all day! The only issue with this eyeliner is you don’t get a ton of product, and if you don’t wear eyeliner everyday it can dry out in the bottle pretty quickly. But it’s cheap so both of those problems aren’t a deal breaker at all!

The color was matte black and it looks great but once it dries if you try touching it or even rubbing it it will fall off it gets all flaky and it’s definitely not waterproof at all, I only knew this cause I hopped in the shower one day and forgot to take my makeup off so it all fell off. It not wat I expected and I’ve had better eyeliners before. I only use it from time to time now but only if I know I’m going somewhere quick. Hope this helps someone

I am a senior and my lids are a little droopy. Therefore, most liners have a tendency of disappearing. Milani is the only liner that actually stays put practically all day long. Love it!!

Ha sido mi delineador por muchos años y hasta el momento no pienso cambiarlo, es fácil de usar, podes hacer trozos rápidos, no se riega y cuando deseas quitarlo, es facil de limpiar.

The only liquid eyeliner that i liked!!!! Its a Matte liner. Stayed for so long and never smudged.

Not as long wear as it says, but goes on easy and is nice

Formula is amazing but the eyeliner applicator isn't pointy but more so flat which I hate....

This is not at all like the Milani Infinite. It certainly does NOT stay put. If you get teary or use hydrating eye drops, expect racoon eyes afterwards. Very disappointed, especially for the cost! ($30 for a huge letdown!)