Johnston & MurphyMen's Hayes Penny Loafer Dress Casual Shoe

Very nice shoe. I wear 11 Wide, and this fit very well right out of the box, with just a little bit of heel slip, easily fixed with a heel pad. Very comfy!!!!!

These are great loafers, at a great price. I have worn identical penny loafers from a famous mens clothing company for decades. Until they changed to a different style. Bought these and could not be more satisfied. Like any loafers they take a few days to break in. But now these are my standard.

I am ending them bak and will order the sae shoe at size 10 1/2. Most shos I fit are 11 however these were too large. They are a beautiful shoe! I will ofder a 10 1/2

My son loved the fit and quality of the shoes. He typically wears AE but was super happy. I was too especially at the price point.

I am VERY dissatisfied. I'm 57yo. I've been wearing JM shoes very regularly for decades. Three mths after owning these shoes and wearing them 1-2x per week [or roughly 12-24x total], one shoe still squeaks noticeably with every step and the heal of the other shoe is already coming off. I likely won't buy JM shoes again.

I loved the look and fit of these loafers! I ordered for myself and im a woman! Wear an 8.5 in women’s ordered a 7 in these men’s loafers. I love the fact that they are 100% leather! Even the soles! Just like the ones I wore as a young women! Love love theseShoes!

These shoes fit nicely but a little snug around the right forefoot. The cushioned lining adds another level of sophistication to these shoes. The only criticism is the color which is not my expectation of burgundy. I bought a burgundy belt to wear with these shoes and the colors are so disparate I am no longer sure which is really burgundy. I would definitely purchase these shoes again in another color!

Certainly a decent shoe for the dollar. They look nice, elegant, classy, and wear well.