JIAYUAN Dog Training Bag Silicone Food Pocket, Hands Free Treats Pouch with Belt Clip and Magnetic Closing

I've purchased many treat holders for dog training over the years and never found a product that strikes a good balance between being able to get to a treat quickly but not allow the treats to fall out when I lean over to pick something up or lure the dog into a "down". This is far and above the best solution I've found...I can grab a treat quickly but they stay in the holder when I bend over. I adopted an alaskan malamute about a week ago and love that I can fill this with treats in the morning, clip it on my waist band, and be able to easily reward him as he learns the "rules of the house". Although I haven't had a need to wash the holder yet, it will be easy to do since it's made from silicone. I highly recommend you give this product a try!

I am only giving this 3 stars because the web description and pictures are misleading/incomplete. I still purchased this because of the waist snap (which is excellent), but this silicone pouch is huge! All other brands had very similar dimensions, so I took a chance this one would be the same. NOT. I could put 4 cups of dry food in the pouch. It is too awkward to have attached to waist band for walks and around the house for training. The closure works fine. However, but since the pouch is so large, bending over or stooping can open the pouch so treats fall out or the pouch comes off your waist band. It would be a great treat pouch if it were smaller. I tried several different styles of treat pouches, silicone and material. For my purposes, the silicone pouch that opens like a coin purse works best.

Absolutely perfect so far for training my pomeranian and my retriever. Holds all but the largest (those huge ‘milk bone’ style) treats, it’s sturdy, closes automatically and it’s an absolute breeze to clean, I chose the bright turquoise blue shade, so I see it right away and remember to always treat train now, the bonus is my pockets aren’t full of crumbs or stains and strange dogs no longer come nosing around my empty coat pockets looking for whatever’s left...It’s a good investment even for owners of older dogs, they love to be rewarded for good behaviors too.Love mine, I’m going to order a few for my other ‘dog parent’ friends.

It's good and easy to use but my only complaint is the clip on it is a pain in the a$$. It doesn't really clip well and you have to make sure that what you clip it too is secure or you'll loose your stuff. It's hard to pinch and make sure that it's open to clip on to something. Just my opinion they would be better off using a different clip. Other than that I love it. It's easy to open and get a treat out. Your hand fits nicely in it. It's quiet so that's nice and yes easy to clean.

I bought this because I thought it would be easy to clean. It is, and I like that feature. But the opening is small, and my hand has trouble getting in and out of the pouch. Also, the clip is not very strong, so it has been knocked off many times. I would recommend this for small dogs and not for training where immediate reward is needed.

This product works well. I’ve had many types over the years and this one seems to work the best. After getting a horse I decided to try this for horse treats. I asked if it would work and the non-English speaking/writing person who was the seller (very broken English) stated only dogs and had no idea that horse treats would fit perfectly. It works well because I no longer have peppermint candies getting washed in my jeans.So no matter what kind of animal you trying to train, it works well.It’s not air tight, but it doesn’t need to be to train.

I was hoping for something that sealed tight enough it would keep the treats fresh. This doesn't and I found the automatic magnetic seal annoying; therefore, it went straight to good will. 3-Stars since it does function as advertised - just not what I wanted.

Lightweight. Easy to clip on and take pooches for a walk. Super easy to access training treats immediately. Only drawback I can come up with is that it's not airtight so maybe not load it up with more treats than dog(s) can consume within several days.